| Platinum | Kiddie Academy of Carmel Westfield |
| Gold | Indiana Montessori Academy |
| Silver | Kiddie Academy of Fisher |
| Bronze | Kiddie Academy of Noblesville |
| Top Pick | A Blessed Child |
| Top Pick | Carmel United Methodist Church Preschool |
| Top Pick | College Nannies, Sitters and Tutors of Carmel |
| Top Pick | Heartland Hall Child Development Center |
| Top Pick | Kiddie Academy of Greenwood |
| Top Pick | The Goddard School |