| Platinum | Titus Bakery & Deli |
| Gold | Graeter's Ice Cream |
| Silver | Handel's Homemade Ice Cream |
| Bronze | BRICS - Broad Ripple Ice Cream Station |
| Top Pick | DeBrand Fine Chocolates |
| Top Pick | Gigi's Cupcakes |
| Top Pick | Gordon’s Milkshakes |
| Top Pick | Paradise Shaved Ice & Ice Cream Shop |
| Top Pick | Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard |